Client testimonials are based on personal experience. Individual results may vary.

RealSelf Reviews of Theo Gerstle, MD

Had concerns with my sagging skin under neck area-lower eyelids-shallow face. The before/after image program that dr. Gerstle used, sealed the deal in going with my procedure.

Dr. Gerstle and his nurse “susan” made my procedure so comfortable for me! Helped me meet transportaion concerns, met me in the office after hours…The list truly does go on and on. These are things that I think the medical field has got away from. Thanks dr. Gerstle for putting the patient first. Big thumbs up!!! – 50 year old male. Lexington, KY

Ladies, I was totally addicted and shopping for doctors to do my boob job. So many of my friends had them & I was so confused about what I wanted and who I should go to for my surgery. I didn’t know what a “cc” even was, let alone how many I wanted in my chest. I just didn’t know what would look good and I was scared to go too big & look cheap, but on the other hand, I didn’t want to go through all of that & be disappointed I didn’t go big enough. I saw Dr. Gerstle at Lexington Plastic Surgery and am so happy that I did. He’s new in town, which made me nervous, but he’s joined a well-established older surgeon and he has great credentials (he went to Harvard! I never knew anyone from Harvard!) and was super nice. He gave me some options about what he thought would look good and asked for my opinion and we hashed out a plan. I ended up getting 300cc implants on each side and I barely have any scars but what a shape I have. I love it. So happy I did this for myself. Dr. Gerstle did such a nice job. I compared mine to my friends & I have to say my boobs/his boob job is better! Next year I’m going back for a tummy tuck & telling all of my friends they need to do the same. I can’t wait! Oh, and he always gives you his cell phone # and email so you can always ask him questions! How awesome is that?! – So So So Happy I Did This for Myself! – Lexington, KY

I have had nothing but a positive experience with Dr. Gerstle and the office staff. His demeanor and bed-side manor is positive, thorough, attentive, flexible, and personal. I had been seeing the same doctor since I was a child for my congenital neurofibromatosis and wanted a different opinion. when I had my consultation with Dr. Gerstle for facial asymmetry due to my neurofibromatosis I was so pleased with how it went, for the first time I felt confident that the results I had always wanted could be achieved. I was overjoyed with the results after my surgery and will continue to see him for anything I need in the future. Dr Gerstle also went over and beyond to help me and accommodate my post-op visits with my work schedule. I would recommend Dr Gerstle to anyone and everyone. – 29 Years Old with Facial Asymmetry

I shopped around for months trying to narrow down which doctor I wanted to perform my Liposuction and Brazillian Butt Lift. After finding Dr. Gerstle, I have to admit that I was a little skeptical because he was so new but after I met him and his staff for the first time, I knew that I was in the right hands. Not only is he very intelligent and dedicated to his practice, but he has a sincere appreciation for his patients. He made me feel welcomed and confident that I would receive the results I was looking for. He took a genuine interest in what I wanted and I am very pleased with the results so far. He’s not done with me yet though so I know more fantastic results are to come. – 25 Year Old Lipo Patient – Lexington, KY

Collected Reviews of Dr. Gerstle from Around the Web


First of all I would like to say that my experience with Dr. Gerstle and his staff has been a blessing! Dr. Gerstle was very detailed in his consultation with me. The before/after images that were done during my consultation was the deciding factor, and helped making my decision to go through with my procedure easier. Dr. Gerstle has walked with me every step of this life changing journey. I highly recommend Dr. Gerstle. Great doctor!!
Edited for spelling and readability.

5 stars; from a review on January 7, 2016 of Dr. Gerstle on

Leave a Review!

If you’d like to leave a review, we recommend one of the following sites. Your feedback helps improve our processes and enriches the community. Thank you for your participation.




Health Grades

  • Contact Us

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.